Jump to content

Examing Muffler for Springs Wear and Muffler Cracking


Runtoeat

Recommended Posts

It pays to inspect the springs and muffler on older aircraft.  The springs may look OK but are pretty worn where they hook onto the muffler.  Also,  I know of one 2008 CTLS which had a crack on the face of the muffler near the muffler's outlet pipe.  This was hard to see but close examination revealed a small white line running about 2".  I note also that there is at least one CTSW has a small brace added by the factory to support the outlet pipe to the muffler body.  My CT does not have this nor did the CT which had a crack.  I'm assuming it has been installed (for some reason on some CT's but not all) to prevent the unsupported cantilevered outlet pipe from causing a crack as a result of it vibrating and "working" the muffler body.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Here's what happened to my exhaust at only around 350 hours, even with good springs and everything appearing to be normal.  I think the issue was poor factory welds and vibration over time.  I recommend keeping a close eye on the condition of your exhaust every time you remove the cowling.

 

20151021_103928_zpsu0oqi0uj.jpg

 

20151021_112231_zpstyaqes6j.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Tom, this confirms what I suspected about the springs wearing.  Andy, I knew your muffler developed a crack but hadn't seen pictures.  Believe Roger helped you repair this at last year's Page event?  I think there might be a good possibility that cracks will eventually develop on a good number of CT's at the weld joint where the outlet pipe is joined to the body and/or on the end of the muffler body near the joint.  Especially on those CT's that don't have the brace.  I envision the non-braced outlet pipe being excited by engine firing at a pretty high amplitude because it is not constrained.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

These cracks occur due to poor stress relief during welding and poor spring tension which allows the exhaust to vibrate in the sockets on top of the muffler. I find way too many springs that have no tension on them. The springs should have 1mm space between coils. Bottom line you should see some light through the coils.

Do not fill your springs full of RTV like Vans does. Rotax used to use this 20+ years ago, but found they retained too much heat without the airspace within the spring which cause premature spring failures. They just broke. Just applying the RTV on the outside allows the spring to dump heat.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I wonder if dynamic propeller balancing might decrease the tendency for these cracks to occur.  Dick, I agree that more planes will show cracks as the fleet ages.  

 

Yes it does as it reduces vibration, and so does keeping the knuckles lubricated. Rotax mentions that when these lock up, cracking results. Install manual Ed 2 Rev 1, 78-00-00, page 3.

 

We've had to repair several exhaust cracks before we got the issue under control by making sure the prop is pitched and balanced, and making sure a good antisieze is used. I strongly recommend nickel for the stainless steel exhausts as it lasts quite a long time, and copper is NOT compatible with stainless as it causes inter-granular corrosion!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I brought this up because it appeared to me muffler cracking might be an issue which Rotax users could experience.  Looks like this is an area Rotax owners must be aware of and should be looking out for on a frequent basis.  I will be replacing some/all of my springs due to the "hooks" being worn as noticed at last conditional inspection. When I replace the springs, I'll also lubricate the joints with nickel based anti-seize. The first thing I did when i bought my CT was to have my prop balanced and pitched correctly.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The first thing I did when i bought my CT was to have my prop balanced and pitched correctly.

 

It does make a huge difference.  When I first got my CTSW the prop was poorly balanced, something like 0.6.  After a dynamic balance it was 0.05, and the difference in smoothness was startling.  I could no longer see the mushroom/binnacle slightly shaking while the engine was running...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...